Those with minimal wear are worth the most. There are plenty of collectors out there looking to add to their collection, whether they are fairly common antique lures, or the rarest of the rare. Wooden and plastic. Creek Chub Pike Vintage Fishing Lures for sale | eBay It's the fishing lure that really put Garrett, Indiana and Creek Chub on the map. If this lure comes with the original box, which in itself is very rare, and if both the lure and the box are in great condition, you could fetch over $18,000 dollars for one of these lures, as some lucky person did in 2012. . Duplication prohibited without permission. Pamela Wiggins is a highly regarded antique and collectible costume jewelry expert and appraiser. Very few examples of this bait are known to exist and rarely do they come up for sale. Patented in 1904 by William Hardy. See all of our vintageSouth Bend lures for sale here. Creek Chub is a favorite among fishing lure collectors as they offered a wide variety not only of baits but some amazing colors. The color is a very tough one, Red Horse Sucker. antique fishing lures and their boxes. 4. A few brands stand out for their collectability and value regarding antique fishing lures. That means an uncatalogued bait color, usually special ordered by a customer / company. At that price, here's hoping it won't be going down to the bottom of a frozen lake. ), out of Garrett, Indiana. Dills also patented a process of painting lures by spraying paint through a screen. The Mohawk minnow was produced in the early 1900s and features a front and rear propeller arrangement and excellent color patterns. We take a look at Heddon and 20 show-stopping lures sold at auction. Creek Chub Lure. The most valuable lures are usually made of wood and have glass eyes. Age:The age of a lure can also impact its value. You see the photos and you can see why these are so collectible and the prices they fetch. This one is in nice shape with just a little wear on the side not shown in the photo. Keep in mind that we may receive commissions when you click our links and make purchases. Creek Chub 1614 Baby Injured Minnow Yellow Spot VG+. They continue to gain in popularity with collectors and have a seemingly endless supply of "special order" colors that were made that have collectors emptying their wallets to complete their collections. The most famous of all the Creek Chub lures is of course the Pikie. Here are some tips for maintaining the condition of your antique fishing lures: Following these care tips and taking preventative measures will ensure the longevity and value of your antique fishing lure collection. Started in 1916 by Henry Dills, Carl Heinzerling and George Shulthless and based out of Garrett, Indiana. The company's first lure was the 'Wiggler,' a basic minnow-type lure. Maybe the nicest example known. (By the way the 1920 date stamped on the lip is the patent date NOT the date the bait was made.). We started with Heddon. Provenance:The history or provenance of a lure might contribute to its worth. While not nearly the success the lures went on to be it has become quite famous with collectors. 10 Rarest and Most Valuable Coins in the World, The High Value of Vintage Christmas Ornaments, 4 Types of Valuable and Vintage Advertising Signs, The Real Value of Tiffany Reproduction Lamps, Guide to Identifying and Valuing Vintage Mechanical Banks, Victorian Furniture Identification and Price Guide, Pocket Watch Identification and Value Guide, Lincoln Memorial Penny: Key Dates, Rarities, and Varieties, Uncirculated U.S. Mint Set Values and Prices. Immell Bait Company Floating Musky Chippewa Minnow With a wooden body and red-painted details, this lure hails from Blair, Wisconsin, and is popular among collectors. See all of our vintage Heddon lures for sale here. 2. I strive to provide the best information when it comes to fishing, whether it is myself or A Fellow Fisherman that is part of my team. If so do you remember where that old tackle box is? This bait is very rare circa 1915 and comes complete with its correct 2 piece Patent Pending picture box in near excellent condition and an unfaded clear paper illustration. Reportedly there is only one of these known to exist in this size. January 24, 2000, you are visitor: This collection was named
No votes so far! Add in the fact that it is uncatalogued on this bait and you have a great price. From the most expensive very early lures that are museum type pieces to lures just a few years old. One can only imagine what a fish would think of this caged minnow that would make them want to inhale it, cage and all. The Wiggletail is a very unusual-looking mechanical vintage lure that makes you scratch your head when you first look at it. Rare items in excellent condition are more valuable than their common counterparts, even if the latter is in equally good condition. $27.00 8 bids $17.05 shipping 5d 3h Creek Chub 4202 Jointed Midget Pikie White & Red Head with Correct End Label Box $14.99 0 bids As you can see in the photo it is a beautiful example of the type of work that went on in Garrett, Indiana. 20 Vintage Heddon Fishing Lures Worth A Fortune: Our follow up article to this one. One wooden example with glass eyes sold for about $600. Home - Fishing Tips & Guides - Most Valuable Rare Antique Fishing Lures: A Collectors Guide. Heddon Dowagiac Casting Bait with Picture Box: Another early Heddon makes the list. Creek Chub Pikie 700 Intro Picture Box and Bait: The 700 Pikie is the lure that went on to become the World Famous Pikie and the bait that really put Creek Chub on the map. Charmer Minnow Made in Springfield, Missouri, this early 1900s barberpole bait features a distinctive red and white striped pattern, making it an attractive item for collectors. Some lucky thrifters have found valuable antiques, and you could too. This website is about collecting
How to Identify This Char Species, Crappie Fishing Gear List: Key Items for Slab Success. If you have one of these rare lures from the early to mid-20th century, it's worth checking into it. The Creek Chub Bait Company out of Garrett, Indiana made some of the most beautiful lures ever assembled. There you have the complete list of twenty-five amazing lures (and some of the most expensive fishing lures ever sold) and the amazing prices they brought recently at auction. We are sorry that this post was not useful for you! We are barely into this article and you can already see a trend. Produced by Riley Haskell with an 1859 patent date. The Truck-Oreno was only made from 1938-1939 adding to the rarity of this lure. Some nearly shimmer in the light. Founded by James Heddon in the late 1800s, their lures are highly sought after for their quality craftsmanship and innovative designs, like the 1897 hand-carved lure that is considered one of the rarest in existence today(Bassmaster). Are Vintage Fishing Lures a Good Investment? The majority of antique fishing lures that are worth quite a bit are typically made out of wood and are hand-painted, and if the lure and paint condition of the lure is good, chances are you can get a pretty penny for one of these rare lures if you choose to sell one. One of Fred Keeling's personal examples. on the metal lip. The Haskell minnow is made of copper, and since these are the rarest of all recreational fishing lures, the chances of finding one are like hitting the jackpot. One look at the baits below and you can see why. This one is one of those. companies include Pflueger, Heddon, Creek Chub, Shakespeare, South Bend, Jamison,
A very nice bait in it's own right. Being one of one simply adds to that. Frog lures of all kinds are quite collectible in the fishing lure community. By clicking Accept All Cookies, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Does it Taste Good? The years of production for each series & the years every catalog color was offered (including the "New Era" colors) within each series. Here is an early Shakespeare fishing lure. 25 Vintage Fishing Lures Worth A Fortune Are They in Your Tackle Box? It's the most expensive fishing lure in the world to ever be sold. Demand:Lastly, the current market demand plays a role in determining the value of old fishing lures. 20 Vintage Heddon Fishing Lures Worth A Fortune: 20 Vintage Creek Chub Fishing Lures Worth A Fortune. Apple Pay The first step in valuing these "mantiques" is to look for a brand such as Heddon, Pflueger, or Creek Chub Bait Co. (also referenced as CCB Co. by collectors and dealers) printed on the lure. Great condition on this bait and a matching 3200 SPECIAL stamped box. Creek Chub is famous for its' colorful paint patterns that have held up amazingly well through the years. This significant lure is believed to be the only of its kind and fetched a little over $6,000 at auction in 2017. This section will discuss the key aspects that determine the value of old fishing lures. CALL US TOLL FREE AT: 833-BUY-LURE (833-289-5873), FREE DOMESTIC SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OF $25 OR MORE. Old Creek Chub Wood and Glass Fishing Lures | Old Antique & Vintage This lure comes with a super tough correctly marked box to just add to the rarity. A guide to the most valuable antique fishing lures, with 350 photos covering 170 companies; how to navigate this antique fishing lures website. It is extremely rare in a Shur-Strike (another brand of Creek Chub baits) Yellow Scale Finish. Creek Chub Lures For Sale | Tough Lures If so, get ready to be blown away by what some of the prices these vintage fishing lures have sold for in the past. Anytime you find a solid color vintage bait, solid red, solid black, etc. As you will see there is some serious money involved in some of these very early baits in great condition. AlsPastTreasures. There are several different types of antique fishing tackle that are worth money, from the copper-built Haskell minnow, the rarest of all old fishing lures, to standard steel lures. We had so much fun writing this one we decided to start looking at the most valuable by manufacturer. Founded by James Heddon in the late 1800s, their lures are highly sought after for their quality . Great condition on this bait but more importantly the box is in spectacular condition and it comes with the box catalog. As you will see there is some serious money involved in some of these very early baits in great condition. As you can imagine not a lot of these survived in good condition. Remember to check for boxes in Grandpa's old tackle box as well as lures. See all of our vintageCreek Chub lures for sale here. Both the bait and box are in nice condition. Ask Grandpa if he has any like these. Authenticating rare antique fishing lures involves examining various aspects of the lure to ensure its legitimacy, rarity, and value. It was exciting to watch this one climb higher and higher, way out of my price pay grade. This one sold for over $13,000 at auction in 2007. The box is not the correct box but still a nice combo and the bait is spectacular. The most popular lure and the most prolific lure was the Pikie. 7 Most Valuable Rare Antique Fishing Lures You Might Actually Own - MSN Robbie
Not many are known to exist (probably even fewer perch colored gar out swimming the waters) but a stunning bait to say the least. You will find educational and historical information on early
hundreds of photos of museum quality antique lures, all in their original boxes. Wooden lure complete with pearl spinners attached. This is one of Creek Chub's most popular colors. Knowing who made the lure you are investigating makes researching the value easier when doing online searches and poring overcompleted item results on eBay.com. If you have a lure by one of these brands or that you think might be valuable, look up the auction prices for similar lures that have sold recently. 3. Tackle Village is reader supported. and collection brought to you by: I BUY ANTIQUE FISHING LURES and will pay up to
Valuable Old Buttons & How to Identify Them. Fishing Lure Values. See all of ourPflueger lures for sale here. This one sold at auction in 2012 for $6,700. It is also essential to avoid exposing them to water, as moisture can lead to rust and deterioration. Creek Chub Wagtail Special 200 Wiggler Fishing Lure 8. Which Companies Made the Most Valuable Old Fishing Lures? It had a metal diving lip. Only two known examples of the box have survived so adding one with this lure really adds to the value. Although modern fishing lures have significantly evolved, studying and collecting antique lures, connect to the early days of recreational fishing and offer insight into the development of tackle technology over time. Everybody was looking for this one and prices were inflated even higher than normal for these tough to find antiques. This Pflueger fishing lure is known as the Live Wire model. My Bait Shop Vault: Our collection of our Rarest and most one of a kind items we come across and offer for sale at My Bait Shop. In uncatalogued "Sunfish" color. There isnt much information out there on how an antique fishing lure appreciates over time, so if you dont want to keep and old fishing lure as a collectible, youre better off selling it at auction. Sold at auction in 2008 for around $9,500. Collectors appreciate Pfluegers creations for their innovative designs and quality workmanship. Creek Chub: Jamison: Outing Mfg. Many of these antique lures are also works of art that were painted by hand. Pavey: 706-955-5625 or email to: rpavey1@comcast.net. A quality antique fishing tackle reference guide
A collectors market for a specific type or brand can drive up prices, even for lures in less-than-perfect conditions. American Express Thrift shops and flea markets are packed with treasures large and small. The paint scheme with stripes on the rear section of the lure is particularly rare, with only one known to exist, and recently, this one-of-a-kind vintage fishing lure sold for $25,000 at auction in 2018. This rare beauty dates from around 1905 and is believed to be the only known example of this bait with a matching wooden box originating from the Mohawk, Florida Heddon location. If you find a wooden fishing lure in great condition, chances are it wasnt fished much and thus can be worth a good amount. The Copper Haskell Minnow is a very rare lure, but there is only one known example of the giant copper Haskell minnow size, and this single example, coupled with the fact that all Haskell minnows are very rare, led to the lure selling at auction for $100,000 dollars. This lure was patented by Riley Haskell in 1859 and is a prime example of lures used in the very early years of recreational fishing in America. 2002-2023 LoveToKnow Media. This is the goldfish coloration, but it came in other colors as well and each version must be evaluated individually in terms of value. This is a centerpiece bait for a 6800 collection for sure. This beautiful bait is a famous 700 Pikie with a correctly marked matching SPECIAL box. This very special 700 Pikie is one of them. There are literally thousands of ways you could go. The Creek Chub Gar is one of the most famous early Creek Chub lures. Creek Chub Lure - Etsy The Best of all the Rest: Early Miscellaneous Fishing Tackle Companies Click Table for Specific Antique Fishing Lures or Click HERE to browse. A rarely seen fishing lure and box combination here. Heddon has made tons of popular lure designs over a long period of time, and in fact, Heddon still produces some of its classic lure designs to this day. The most famous of all the Creek Chub lures is of course the Pikie. Click HERE
This one sold at auction in 2019 for $3,800. All rights reserved. Etsy. The key to the success of these early 1900s lures was the "gem clip," a see-through hardware system that made the lure look more realistic when you used it. We take a look at Heddon and 20 show-stopping lures sold at auction. Despite that it sold for an astounding $42,500. Heddon, Shakespeare, and Creek Chub baits, Pardee, and Pflueger lures are the more commonly found fishing lures, and they . collect. The final sales price was just over $9,400. Complete with a tail mechanism and fin design that clearly helps it stand out from others. For example, keeping them inHardy Interchangeable Casting Minnow BoxorHardys Silvered Minnow Boxcan help protect them. So on to the next giant in American Fishing Lure History, The Creek Chub Bait Company (C.C.B.C.O. This was the last of the six pack assortments they offered and in my opinion the most beautiful one. Creek Chub Nickel Finish Wigl-Y-Rind $39.00. $295.00. In antique fishing lures, collectors seek out rare and valuable pieces that exemplify the craftsmanship and history behind these unique fishing tools. Creek Chub Lures - Etsy We start with the number one lure coming in at a whopping $101,200 and count down from there. Creek Chub History: Creek Chub Bait Company history and information at My Bait Shop. It is extremely rare in a Shur-Strike (another brand of Creek Chub baits) Yellow Scale Finish. When you hear about the high prices of vintage fishing lures this is the one everybody is talking about. It sold at auction in 2017 for just over $5,500. See the ones marked CCBCO, GARRETT IND and 9-7-20 or 9-27-20? However, this does not impact our reviews and comparisons. Pflueger lures sometimes have rhinestone eyes, like this one, in colors to coordinate with the body. 17 Most Valuable Rare Antique Fishing Lures Worth Money Somevery rare examplescan be worth more than $20,000. This lure combination is one of the rarest miscellaneous early baits and was made by the Artificial Bait Company out of Monticello, Indiana. Among these treasured brands are Heddon, Shakespeare, Creek Chub, Pardee, and Pflueger. Consult an experienced collector or expert for guidance on proper care and handling techniques, mainly when dealing with rare or delicate lures. The addition of an original box adds to the value of this auction lot. Most Valuable Rare Antique Fishing Lures: A Collector's Guide They only made a lot of these for a short period of time with most of them ending before 1950. If you are a Wiggle Fish collector, this piece is front and center in your collection. Each one must be evaluated individually when determining value since some Punkinseeds sell for $25 and others are worth several hundred dollars depending on how they are decorated. . The Musky Charmer Minnow comes in at 5 inches in length, being the largest of all charmer minnows, and there are only a few known to be in existence today. It's been a few years now but this one sold for over $100,000 at auction. 3. ), out of Garrett, Indiana. Here's a rare entry. The lure and matching box are both in Excellent condition. 2000-2016 by Robbie Pavey. Hi, I'm Captain Tyler Brady, founder of A Fellow Fisherman. This one is a 5500 Jointed Snook Pikie in color 36 Black Sucker with the matching box marked SPECIAL 5536 box. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. One of these "special" baits is this Creek Chub Plunker. Creek Chub 2400 Wiggle Fish Special Green Scale Color: Here's a beauty.